Microsoft IE8 Comparison Chart – “Of course Internet Explorer 8 wins this one”

I nearly lost my lunch when I saw the chart below. It’s a comparison chart between Internet Explorer 8 (IE8), Firefox and Chrome. I should note that I am an IE user – I run different things in IE and Firefox.

Microsoft took an internal comparison look at the following categories: security, privacy, ease of use, web standards, developer tools, reliability, customizability, compatibility, manageability and performance.

I am using IE7 so I can’t comment on how good or bad IE8 is but it’s a bit odd that a company would show a chart that makes their browser look amazingly better than the competition. IE8 wins or ties in every category and some of the comments seem like an agency was involved. Here are a couple of examples, “Of course Internet Explorer 8 wins this one”  and “Neither Firefox nor Chrome provide guidance or enterprise tools. That’s just not nice.” Is there really not one area that Firefox or Chrome is better than IE8? (I have no idea so someone educate me plz)

My advice to Microsoft is to just sell us on why IE8 is great – don’t worry about comparisons – we will take care of those as users.

It looks like Microsoft is trying to come across as cutsie but it just didn’t work for me. Did it work for you? Leave your thoughts in the comments below.

RSS Feed
RSS
8 COMMENTS
  1. Dan Grossman says:

    Don’t forget, only 8% of people in street testing can tell you what a browser is.

    This will work just fine for them.

  2. Jerry says:

    Oh, you don’t believe us? Next week we’ll throw at you another chart featuring Bing vs Google.

    • Ryan says:

      Good one, Jerry.

      Google Chrome & Mozilla Firefox are the best browsers.
      My favorite browser is Google Chrome.
      I’m a web developer.
      I test my sites using browsers like Chrome, Firefox,Opera,Safari,IE etc.
      Mostly my site will work perfectly in all browsers, except IE.
      IE causes wasting my whole day fixing specific IE errors.
      I request Microsoft to stop IE.
      And about their comparison chart : Laugh loudly and increase your life span.
      Coming soon : Bing vs Google
      Now Microsoft started lying too..!!
      I hate IE !!

  3. Ron says:

    With props to Chrome for running java-based web apps faster, I’ve been using IE8 for a while now and for general browsing I find it the least irritating of the big 3 (IE8 java is like 4x faster than IE7 now, which does help a lot). Firefox takes for-freaking-ever to load and still crashes more than IE + there’s more basic plug-in crap to deal with (like Windows media compatibility – hellooo?). The security of FF and IE is comparable – those tired old claims that Firefox is more secure (unless you’re using NoScript on most pages) are just plain baloney. Firefox is great for super-extensibility but the large majority of people (all but the 8% who know what a browser is!) will be more irritated by Firefox or Chrome than by IE. They just want to quickly launch their “Google Browser” and facebook and online banking and get on with it.

    Having said all that, that comparison chart is hilarious. It looks like someone at MS just roughed one out as a tongue-in-cheek draft and someone published it by accident.

  4. Andreas says:

    Where is the comparison to Safari?

  5. Allen Stern says:

    yea Andreas – they don’t care about mac :)

  6. High End says:

    What about Opera? After years of being a “hardcore nerd” i use Opera for my general browsing. The features are so good. (Speed Dial?!)

    Sure i have Firefox just incase there are some compatibility issues, but other then that Opera wins in every category as far as i’m concerned. Speed, Security, Ease of Use, and Reliability? Yes Sir. It’s great that microsoft now offer BOTH tab isolation and data recovery. Only over a year behind Opera?

    I only felt the need to comment because of that outrageous chart. Normally i let people be happy with supporting the big companies offering sub-innovative products at excessive prices.

  7. Danyal says:

    There’s always someone banging on about Opera.

Leave a Reply

Become a sponsor

SPONSORS

Loop11
Clicky Web Analytics
CloudContacts
125px
Future of Web Design
Advertise here

STARTUP NEWS

twitter