Mint Archive

I get various requests from time to time asking me which analytics applications. So here is my list of the current analytics applications I use on my web sites with a short bit of commentary on each one. They are not listed in any particular order. You can also check out my previous post which offers several free and almost-free analytics options. I don’t believe most Web sites need the insane number of tools I run but each one offers me something unique and, in addition, I like to test as well.

Clicky

Clicky is currently my favorite analytics application. The interface is excellent, has a Web 2.0 feel to it without going overboard. The best features are the real-time spy and the IP user lookup. The user maps and location information is very detailed giving you insights into where your users are, how they access your site, and what they do on your site.

General comments:

• The basic account is limited to 1,000 pageviews per day. Most users will want the $2.99 plan.
• There is an affiliate program which earns credits towards free premium memberships.
• Support is great and the site is very user-friendly.
• Clicky is also running an API contest currently. So far I know of one entry at ideAjax which basically is a sweet world map.

eXTReMe Tracking

eXTReMe Tracking has the absolute best user lookup tools that I have found to-date. If you want to be able to look at individual users and their patterns, eXTReMe Tracking does this very well. The rest of the app is strong, but not the strongest of the tools listed.

General comments:

• The free account is limited and requires you to place a graphic on your site. The pro account is $4.50 a month.
• The "on the map" feature is the best user mapping tool I have tried. In fact, Dateline NBC used it on a sting operation last year.
• The site does have a short learning curve and the interface layout could be improved.

Google Analytics

I have used Google Analytics since they first launched and the new version is very powerful. I don’t love GA but keep it running because it is generally the best comparison from site-to-site.

General comments:

• Some users report that the Goals options don’t always track correctly
• I am not crazy about Google controlling every aspect of my site including the site traffic.
• Overall, this is the most popular analytics app for three reasons: Google’s trust level, their ability to market it thru the AdWords program and that the app is free.

Mint

I like Mint. It is the fastest of the analytics applications listed and it runs on your local server. I used to believe it was better to keep everything on your local server with regards to analytics apps, but today there ASP model apps have really improved their ability to track and not lose data.

General comments:

• There is no free plan, $30 gets you a license for the current x.y version. Once x is upgraded, the charge is $15.
• There is an excellent support community who can help with support and extending the app.
• Mint offers "Peppers" which are basically add-ons to extend the functionality of the app. Most are built by the Mint community.

Quantcast

Quantcast is the odd man out in this grouping. Quantcast doesn’t provide as much detail as the above and is really used as a ranking and evaluation tool. Sites that use their plugin are called "Quantified Publishers" on the site. Frankly I wish more sites would use this because then it could create more fair comparisons. Quantcast is what Alexa wishes it would be.

Final summary

I left Complete off the list because I am currently working with them to attempt to rectify the reporting issues on CN. Once they have corrected the issues, I will post my thoughts on Complete. I have not included the "professional" level packages such as Webtrends, Omniture and WebSideStory. Lastly, many web hosting packages provide basic metrics applications. I didn’t include these because I find that they are generally worthless and out-of-date.

What tools are you using? Is it one (or more) of the above? Are there others I should be reviewing/testing?

Doing proper analysis of your web app or blog is critical to its success. It is vital that you monitor the who, what, when, where and why visitors are coming to your web site. If you expect to get VC money or to be able to sell advertising, you must prove the traffic your site receives. I love analytics and have reviewed somewhere close to 200 tools over the years. I have come up with what I consider to be five of the top analytics tools that are either free or very low cost. These tools will help you answer the 5 w’s of your web site. List is in no specific order and all of the tools I am suggesting just require a few lines of javascript code in your footer include to get them working. Less than 10 minutes setup.

ExtremeTracking

Product Link | Product Demo

Price: $54/yr or $6.25/month full version, free version also available – must show stats icon

Pros:

• Excellent IP tools – find out exactly where your visitors are coming from down to the individual company or location
• You can drill down to a specific page and get all of the stats just for that individual page
• Tracks connection speed, OS, browser, java/javascript, screen colors and resolutions
• CSV downloads
• Ability to exclude IPs from reporting (good for excluding yourself, team, etc.)

Cons:

• Poor history – only offers full access for last 300 visitors, then is grouped by day, week, etc.
• Not the prettiest thing in the world
• Free version allows anyone to view your stats

Screenshots – click to enlarge

Mint

Product Link | Product Demo

Price: $30 one-time

Pros:

• Very Web 2.0, excellent design and usability
• Lots of “Pepper” – plugins
• a forum for help and the creator actually helps with installation and usage questions
• RSS Feeds

Cons:

• History is limited beyond 24 hours back
• No ability to customize time period for reports
• No export option outside of RSS
• Only can exclude one IP address

Screenshots – click to enlarge

Google Analytics

Product Link | Product Tour

Price: Free

Pros:

• Tied in with Google AdWords and Google Checkout
• Free and no icon required
• Provides good basic stats
• Good export options – text, csv, xml

Cons:

• Not the most indepth tool
• Works the best when you use AdWords and/or Checkout
• Can’t exclude IPs

Screenshots – click to enlarge

HitBox

Product Link | Product Demo

Price: $323/yr, $34.95/month

Pros:

• Full featured web analytics tool
• Ability to receive reports via e-mail
• Provides good basic stats
• Good export options – text, csv, xml

Cons:

• Higher cost
• Reports limited to 100 web pages
• Reports are huge and take some time to generate

Screenshots – click to enlarge

SiteMeter

Product Link | Product Demo

Price: Free, must display stats icon

Pros:

• Real-time stats
• Ability to receive reports via e-mail
• Provides good basic stats
• Pretty cool traffic predictor

Cons:

• Must display a SiteMeter icon on your site
• Heavy advertising on report display
• Not the prettiest design

Screenshots – click to enlarge

Summary

I use Mint, Google Analytics and ExtremeTracking on CenterNetworks. I think together they provide the most comprehensive coverage for my needs. Each tool has its own pros and cons so you can decide what you need/want for your web site/blog. I would suggest at a minimum you use Google Analytics because it is free. And get it working today. Each day you wait, is another day of no ability to speak to your traffic. Even if you never look at a report, do it anyway. When you get your funding, sell the site, or get your first advertiser, you can thank me :).